PG Soft Modal 20K, Scatternya Ngamuk di Mahjong Ways Top508 Main Santai Mahjong Ways Top508, Jepeh 3 Juta Pola 30X Terbukti Gacor, Lihat Hasilnya di Mahjong Ways Top508 Tes Pola Baru Mahjong Ways Top508, Bikin Hoki Nggak Masuk Akal Mahjong Ways Top508, Scatternya Beruntun Modal Receh Cuan Jam Gacor Malam Bikin Modal 50K Meledak di Mahjong Ways Top508 Tanpa Buy Spin, Sukses Dapat Double Scatter di Top508 Strategi Pola Mix Jadi Kunci Jepeh di Mahjong Ways Top508 15 Menit Main, Scatter Mahjong Ways Top508 Ngamuk 3x Surga Mahjong Ways Ada di Top508, Pola Gacor Auto Cuan Modal 20K Meledak! Mahjong Ways Lagi Panas Parah di BEST808 Pola Rahasia Mahjong Ways yang Bikin Scatter Ngamuk di BEST808 Iseng Coba Pola 30x, Eh Jackpot! Mahjong Ways BEST808 Emang Beda! Jam Gacor Malam Hari Terbukti Ampuh di Mahjong Ways BEST808! Pola Malam Mahjong Ways Paling Gacor — Hanya di BEST808! Pemula Pun Bisa Jepeh! Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Gampang Banget! Nggak Masuk Akal! Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Gacor Sebrutal Ini? Scatter Hitam Muncul Terus! Modal 25K Jadi Kaya di BEST808 BEST808 Lagi Royal! Mahjong Ways Modal Kecil Bisa Jadi Sultan! Pakai Trik Sederhana, Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Langsung Cuan! Cuan Gampang, Ini Cara Main Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Tanpa Ribet Rahasia Slot Mahjong Ways di BEST808, Modal Tipis Hasil Fantastis Main Mahjong Ways di BEST808, Coba Trik Ini Biar Langsung Profit Auto JP! Mahjong Ways BEST808 Buka Jalan Cuan Lewat Trik Sederhana Slot Mahjong Ways di BEST808, Kombinasi Strategi dan Keberuntungan Begini Cara Main Mahjong Ways BEST808 yang Bikin Dompet Tebal Main Tenang, Cuan Datang! Mahjong Ways BEST808 Bukan Slot Biasa Trik Main Mahjong Ways di BEST808 yang Sering Dipakai Pemain Pro Taklukkan Slot Mahjong Ways BEST808 dengan Gaya Main Efektif Ini Dari Modal Kecil Jadi Cuantastic, Mahjong Ways BEST808 Punya Jurusnya Cuan Maksimal, Ini Cara Main Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Tanpa Modal Besar Trik Jitu Mahjong Ways di TOP508, Bikin Spin Jadi Cuan Tiap Hari Slot Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Tawarkan Pola Menang yang Konsisten Gaya Main Santai Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Bisa Bawa Jackpot Serius Mahjong Ways TOP508, Slot Andalan Buat Pemain yang Cari Untung Stabil Main Mahjong Ways di TOP508, Gunakan Strategi Ini untuk Hasil Lebih Baik Spin Cerdas Mahjong Ways TOP508 Jadi Jalan Cepat Menuju Profit Kenapa Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Jadi Favorit Pemburu Slot Gacor Rekomendasi Trik Mahjong Ways TOP508 yang Cocok untuk Pemula dan Pro Pola Menang Mahjong Ways TOP508 Terbongkar, Ini Cara Mainnya Cara Main Mahjong Ways di OJI99 yang Bikin Setiap Spin Berasa Jackpot Trik Mahjong Ways OJI99 Paling Dicari Pemain Slot Online Tahun Ini Auto Cuan Main Mahjong Ways di OJI99 Cuma Pakai Strategi Sederhana Mahjong Ways OJI99 Slot Favorit dengan Pola Menang Konsisten Ubah Modal Receh Jadi Cuan Lewat Mahjong Ways di OJI99 Rahasia Mahjong Ways di OJI99 yang Jarang Diketahui Pemain Baru Spin Santai Bisa Cuan, Mahjong Ways OJI99 Cocok Buat Semua Gaya Main Incar Scatter dan Multiplier, Mahjong Ways OJI99 Kasih Potensi Menang Besar Mahjong Ways di OJI99 Banyak Bonusnya, Ini Saat Terbaik Buat Main Mahjong Ways OJI99 Pilihan Cerdas Buat Pemain Slot yang Cari Profit Rutin Mahjong Ways TOP508 Jadi Primadona Baru Saat Banyak Orang Ingin Cuan Tanpa Risiko Berlebih Mencari Penghasilan Tambahan Tanpa Ribet? Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Jawabannya Di Tengah Lesunya Ekonomi, Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Tawarkan Peluang Cuan yang Stabil Fenomena Mahjong Ways di TOP508, Strategi Cerdas Tambah Income dengan Modal Minim Banyak Orang Beralih ke Mahjong Ways TOP508, Rahasia Cuan Konsisten di Era Sulit Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Jadi Tren Baru Para Pencari Income Ringan dan Cepat Cuan Aman dan Legal Lewat Mahjong Ways TOP508, Tawarkan Pola yang Terbukti Efektif Gaya Baru Tambah Penghasilan, Mahjong Ways di TOP508 Ramah untuk Pemula dan Minim Risiko Mahjong Ways TOP508 Menjadi Pilihan Favorit di Tengah Kebutuhan Cuan Tambahan Harian Tak Perlu Modal Besar, Mahjong Ways TOP508 Hadirkan Cara Cerdas Tambah Pemasukan Ketika Waktu Luang Bisa Jadi Cuan: Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Buktikan Permainan Bisa Produktif Bukan Sekadar Game: Mahjong Ways BEST808 Tawarkan Potensi Penghasilan Tambahan Setiap Hari Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Bantu Banyak Orang Atasi Kebutuhan Finansial Tanpa Harus Kerja Lembur Penghasilan Tambahan Tanpa Tinggalkan Rumah? Mahjong Ways BEST808 Pilihannya Game Online Bisa Jadi Jalan Keluar Finansial? Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Buktikan Bisa! Pola Cuan Subuh di Mahjong Ways BEST808 Jadi Rahasia Komunitas Online Dapat Pemasukan Tambahan Meski Ekonomi Melemah, Mahjong Ways BEST808 Bantu Banyak Orang Tetap Produktif dari Rumah Langkah Awal Cuan Digital: Kenapa Banyak Pemula Pilih Mahjong Ways di BEST808? Mahjong Ways BEST808 Sediakan Solusi Realistis Tambah Income Tanpa Skill Khusus Mengisi Waktu Kosong dengan Cuan: Mahjong Ways di BEST808 Jadi Aktivitas Favorit Baru
object based audio and large number of speakers - Ask A Pro - Home Acoustics Alliance Portal
Home / Ask A Pro

Ask A Pro


Back to Ask A Pro...

object based audio and large number of speakers (4 replies)

Rajdeep S
8 years ago
Rajdeep S 8 years ago

can we get wide sweet spot by using more number of speakers in a small room?

Qiang C
8 years ago
Qiang C 8 years ago

false       because  listeners are closer to speakers which reduces the good listening area(sweet spot)   many of the acoustical design principles utilized in large spaces fail to compensate for small room problems

chen qiang

Gerry Lemay
8 years ago
Gerry Lemay 8 years ago
1 like by Rajdeep S

The question is not as simple as you might think; there are two factors at work.  The first factor relates to the definition of the sweet spot or sweet area.  As interpreted by the HAA, this is the listening area in the room where Focus is optimized.  This means that the LCR speakers create a balanced sound field and allow placement of stereo images in the proper position and size (i.e. Focus) in the soundstage.  We traditionally calculate the locations where LCR speaker sound levels are balanced and Focus is perfected as being within a triangular area; the sweet triangle. The concept put forward by Trinnov is that by adding more speakers, the dependence of Focus on stereo imaging is reduced by simply placing more speakers in between the usual pair of imaging speakers.  Theoretically, one can render stereo imaging as unneeded by simply installing enough speakers to allow the creation of an image at any given location by virtue of placing a speaker at that location. 

Imagine the scenario of an infinite number of speakers representing every possible position one would expect to hear a focused image.  Every sonic image would be heard directly from a single speaker or closely placed pair of speakers perfectly localizing the desired image location.  Such a mono source delivered by a single speaker has no defined sweet spot; listeners will hear the image location perfectly from any room location.  Instead of a true stereo image we hear the speaker(s) located where the image should be placed.  The question I believe Trinnov explores is at what quantity of speakers does one achieve this kind of coverage short of infinity.  I'll report back once I better understand this question. 

The other factor I mentioned is actually not about the sweet spot size but rather about speaker localization.  A listener located a short distance from any speaker (8 ft or so) makes it much easier to notice the presence of a speaker.  Even with multiple speakers, the listening area will be limited by the proximity of surround speakers.  In this case, not only would the image of a panning object allow the localization of a nearby speaker but also the bed channel ambient background could also allow speaker localization.  Speaker localization reduces envelopment and the immersive effect.  In HAA we call this the Exit Door Effect.  Ganging all speakers to reproduce bed channel sounds would allow them to play at a lower level, however the object information would still need to be reproduced at the proper level of the individual speaker.

Another issue that needs to be considered is the quality of the processing.  While the accuracy of Dolby's Atmos object placement is not being questioned, many times sounds are recorded in a natural way depicting not only the image location of the sound but also an intricate network of simultaneously recorded instruments and all recorded reflections which help render a better three-dimensional depiction of the sound.  An example might be a string quartet in a small chamber room recorded with only two microphones.  The recorded spatial information is considered best reproduced by the same number speakers as microphones.  I'm a fan of the new Dolby Surround processing changing stereo to 7.1 but I'm curious how such a complex alignment of sounds will be rendered through so many more speakers.  I'm not a doubter but mainly curious.  One of the criticisms of Dolby Atmos versus Aura involves this delicate reproduction of such precisely recorded soundtracks... but then that's for audiophiles and not so much for movies.

Bottom line is that, the assertion that the sweet spot is enlarged with a greater number of speakers is essentially true but dependent on more factors than simply adding a few more speakers.  7.1.4 system does not expose any advantage of this kind over a 7.1 system in a small room.  Maybe 11.1.6?  But probably not.  I am keen to discover just how many speakers are needed to capitalize on this concept and in what size room.  I'll work on this and report back.

 

 

Li Zi J
8 years ago
Li Zi J 8 years ago

An expanding range of desserts area can increase the listener appropriately, if the room listener too many, will cause the listener distance is too close to a speaker, thus affecting the listening effect.

Gerry Lemay
8 years ago
Gerry Lemay 8 years ago
1 like by Rajdeep S
Accepted answer

Yes the "desserts" area or sweet area is expanded just as the sweet triangle is expanded by adding the center channel.  There is still a "red" zone near closely placed speakers.

Back to Ask A Pro...

Top